The Syed Brothers' Coup & Bajirao Vishwanath's Triumph (1719)
Marathi History Book Reading Session Summary
The Day After: Searching for the Emperor
The Morning After the Palace Intrusion
What Happened:
- Emperor Farooq Shiar kicked Syed brothers out of his court
- "Screw you guys" - rejecting their demands
- Fled to the women's quarters (zenana)
- Syed brothers searching for him
- No one sure what's going to happen
- Takes one more day
- New day arrives
The Massacre in Delhi Streets
1,000 Marathas Killed
The Violence:
"1,000 Maratha folks were killed in the streets of Delhi."
The Timing:
"Before it was known that the emperor has been arrested by Syed brothers."
Context:
- Maratha forces in Delhi
- Caught in the violence
- Before news spread about coup
- Chaos in the streets
The Nizam Stays Neutral
The Powerful Courtier's Decision
Who Is Nizam:
"Nizam is basically an emperor appointed official in certain areas, like Hyderabad."
His Title:
- Nizam = title (not a personal name)
- Emperor-appointed official
- Like a Subedar but more powerful
- "Hyderabad Nizam" - very well known
His Background:
- Allied with Aurangzeb originally
- Later became more and more independent
- Had his own kingdom
- During Aurangzeb rule = too powerful to defy
- After Aurangzeb = slowly independent
His Status:
- Powerful courtier
- Influential
- Well-positioned
- Could have intervened
His Choice:
"The Nizam stayed neutral."
What This Means:
- Won't help Farooq Shiar
- Won't oppose Syed brothers
- Staying out of it
- Self-preservation
Finding the Emperor: The Women's Quarter
The Search
The Setting:
"In the women's quarter, all these queens - because the emperor typically had several so-called wives and also they had a lot of unofficial concubines."
The Protection:
- Women wouldn't release the target
- Not Farooq Shiar they were protecting
- They were protecting Bidar Ali (or Bidar Dil)
- Another princeling Syed brothers wanted
Understanding the Royal Family Danger
Why The Women Were Protective
The Problem:
"There were several of these princelings running around."
The Fear #1: Brother Killing Brother
"If one came into power, he may view his brothers as a threat."
The Fear #2: The Syed Brothers' Intentions
"They thought that Syed brothers wanted to establish their own rule. They may slaughter these people because unless they slaughter them, they can't come to power."
The Calculation:
- To truly take power = must eliminate royal family
- All princelings = potential claimants
- Syed brothers = threat to all of them
- Women trying to protect the princes
The Numbers:
"There were several princelings because Aurangzeb may have had several wives and several concubines and there can be several great grandsons and grandsons and stuff like that. There's a lot of them."
The Compromise Emperor: Rafi-ul-Darajat
When They Couldn't Get Their First Choice
The Problem:
- Women wouldn't release Bidar Ali/Bidar Dil
- Syed brothers needed someone quickly
- Had to have someone from royal family
The Solution:
"Rafi-ul-Darajat - this is the princeling who they got hold of. They simply brought him out and put him on the throne."
Why:
"They wanted to have somebody representing the royal family because it has to be from the family."
- Legitimacy requires royal blood
- Can't just take power themselves
- Need figurehead emperor
- This prince will do
Dealing with the Ex-Emperor
Finding Farooq Shiar
What Happened:
"Then they somehow found him in the women's quarter. They brought him out. And they blinded him right there."
Then:
"And then they put him in the prison."
The Poem:
- While blinded and imprisoned
- Farooq Shiar wrote a poem about his situation
- Describing his fate
The Escape Attempt: Bribing the Guards
Planning to Flee to Jodhpur
The Plan:
"He tried to give a bribe to his guards to let him go to his father-in-law in Jodhpur - some Rajput guy."
The Family Connection:
- His wife = princess from Jodhpur
- Her father = the Jodhpur ruler
- Wife's father = father-in-law
- Wanted refuge with her family
Jodhpur:
- In Rajasthan
- City kingdom
- Vassal king but autonomous
- Rajput stronghold
The Marriage:
"So he was married to a princess from Jodhpur."
Why This Made Sense:
- Rajput family = military power
- Could protect him
- Gather support from Rajputs
- Potential base for comeback
The Final Solution: Assassination
When The Syed Brothers Heard
The News:
"This news went up to Syed brothers."
The Decision:
"Now they decided to finish him off."
Why:
"So far they blinded him and imprisoned him. But if he were to escape, then he becomes a liability because he can come back to throne."
The Danger:
"Because he is a king - even though he was kicked out. But if he gathers some protection and some support from the Rajput side, then it will be difficult."
The Killers for Rent
Bhadotri Marekari
What It Means:
- Killers for rent
- Professional assassins
- Hired guns
What They Did:
"In a few days, they got [it done]."
The Puppet Show Analogy
The New Emperor's Real Status
The Comparison:
"Remember that there are people who have these dolls that they operate by remote."
Modern Term:
- Puppet show
- Marionettes
- Controlled by strings
The Reality:
"The new emperor who was like - he had no power base at all."
What This Meant:
"Through him, Syed brothers got all the rewards met."
- Complete puppet
- No independent power
- Syed brothers pull the strings
- Emperor just signs what they want
The Maratha Rewards: Everything They Wanted
What Bajirao Vishwanath Got
Reward #1: Release the Hostages
"One of the important ones was to relieve Yesubhai and Madan Singh."
Who They Were:
- Madan Singh = not directly Sambhaji's legal son
- "His concubine son, kind of"
- "Half son, you can say"
- Yesubhai = another hostage
The Release:
"Yesubhai and some other people, they were let go. So [Bajirao] was able to leave with them."
Reward #2: The Chautai Rights
The Tax Rights:
"They also got the Chautai rights for that land, which was huge."
What This Meant:
- Right to collect Chauth (one-fourth tax)
- Enormous revenue
- Major financial win
- Economic power
Reward #3: Three Imperial Orders (Sanads)
The Documents:
"They got three orders signed off by the new emperor."
The First Order: Six Provinces in Deccan
Tax Collection Rights
What It Granted:
"One of them granted the Marathas the right of collecting taxes of six provinces in Dakhan."
The Fourth Order: Sardeshmukhi
One-Tenth Tax
What It Granted:
"According to the second order that was signed, Marathas got the right to collect one-tenth of the tax."
Sardeshmukhi:
- Additional 10% tax
- On top of Chauth (25%)
- Combined = 35% of revenue!
- Massive income stream
The Third Order: THE BIG ONE
Recognition of Maratha Kingdom
What It Granted:
"According to the third order that was signed, the emperor accepted the Maratha kingdom."
Why This Was HUGE:
"Which had never happened before. Aurangzeb said they were always illegitimate, just some rebels."
The Significance:
- First time official recognition
- No longer rebels
- Legitimate kingdom
- Imperial sanction
The Reaction:
"Marathas really were delighted. And this is a big, huge accomplishment of Balaji Vishwanath."
The Opposition in Court
The Hardliners Were Furious
Who Opposed:
"The emperor's court had a lot of powerful [nobles]. They were opposed to these orders."
Why:
- Maybe their current land/Jagir/Subeda
- More importantly: hardliners in the court
- "Hate to see the Marathas gaining any advantage"
The History:
"That's why Farooq Shiar was rejecting these demands. And it was a sign of weakness. Because he was with the hardliners."
The Ambush: Stealing the Orders
The Smart Strategy
What Happened:
"When they got the signed orders from the emperor in the Lal Red Fort, then one of the Peshwa officials basically gave the copies to Bajirao Vishwanath and told him to go to wherever they were staying in Delhi."
The Split:
- Copies = given to Bajirao Vishwanath
- Originals = taken by the Peshwa official
- Official left by different route
Why:
"Maybe they were afraid that these orders will be confiscated by the Mughal officers from Bajirao Vishwanath. And they won't end up following it or something."
The Attack on the Wrong Guy
What The Hardliners Did
The Ambush:
"When Bajirao Vishwanath was going to his [camp], they attacked and they got hold of those orders."
Their Goal:
- Take away the evidence
- "Marathas got to have those orders" = can't execute
- "At least in minimum they can delay this or make it non-existent"
The Violence:
"And in that he was killed."
But:
- He only had copies
- The originals were with Bhanu (the other official)
- Safe with different person, different route
The Result:
"So there are some rumors about these orders, officially signed letter. So there's a lot of details around this. It wasn't a clear or cleanly executed order initially. So there was lots of opposition beyond just Farooq Sihan."
The Final Authority
What Made It Legitimate
The Result:
"So now officially Marathas were in charge of their kingdom because the emperor in Delhi had agreed everything that they wanted."
Why It Mattered:
"Nobody could take any exception because this was signed off by the Delhi emperor. So what more do you want?"
The Legitimacy:
"It was then accepted all over India because Mughal was the preeminent power no matter whether they were paper tiger or not. Once they accepted then it became authentic that this is Maratha kingdom of Shahu and nobody could say 'where is your legitimacy?'"
The Power of Recognition:
"Because the Mughals had accepted it. The Mughal emperor said yes. And that means that's that."
Shahu's Reaction
The King's Joy
The Response:
"Shahu must have been very happy. He got everything he wanted and more."
His Confidence:
"So his confidence in Balaji Vishwanath really was at the very peak."
The Honor:
"Shahu was so elated and happy that he honored Balaji Vishwanath as a very important servant of Maratha kingdom. And he was further honored."
The Young Witness: Bajirao's Education
What The 20-Year-Old Learned
Who Was There:
"And all along, his son Bajirao is with him while this is happening. He was a 20-year-old kid at the time. And so he's come to Delhi. He's witnessed all of this happen."
What He Saw:
"So now Bajirao saw everything in Delhi. He understood everything about Mughal emperor and what situation prevailed."
The Crucial Insight: The Mughal Paper Tiger
What Bajirao Realized
The Understanding:
"And he understood that this Mughal emperor is just - I mean, the whole thing is coming down."
The Crucial Insight:
"So that was a crucial insight for him to be able to get that glimpse."
The Reality:
"He realized that Mughal emperor is only effective in Delhi alone. Beyond that, nobody gives him a damn. And so things are changing."
The Shivaji Parallel
Two Generations, Same Lesson
Shivaji's Experience:
"Remember, Shivaji also, when he came to Agra, he saw the whole - I mean, it was a different Agra. It was totally controlled by Mr. Aurangzeb. But he saw with his own eyes."
Bajirao's Experience:
"And the same thing happened to Bajirao Peshwa."
The Difference:
"But of course, they were at different times in the empire."
- Shivaji saw Aurangzeb's strong empire
- Bajirao saw the collapsing empire
- Both got firsthand view
- Both learned from seeing
Why This Mattered for History
The Future Peshwa's Formation
The Importance:
"It is important because then Bajirao Peshwa becomes whole and soul of Maratha empire later on. And what he saw in Delhi was extremely important."
The Impact:
"It influenced all of his decisions and battles after that."
The Realization:
"But he understood that Mughal empire is gone. And that there's a power vacuum forming. And they only ruled the city of Delhi. That's it."
The Contrast:
"At the time Aurangzeb had the kind of terror and the kind of rule that he had is gone. And it wasn't like that anymore. It was a paper tiger."
Key Players
| Name | Role | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Farooq Shiar | Mughal Emperor | Blinded, imprisoned, then killed |
| Syed Brothers | Kingmakers | Orchestrated coup, installed puppet |
| Rafi-ul-Darajat | New Emperor | Puppet with no power base |
| Bidar Ali/Bidar Dil | Princeling | Protected by women, Syed's first choice |
| Balaji Vishwanath | Peshwa | Secured all Maratha demands |
| Bajirao | Vishwanath's son | 20 years old, witnessed everything |
| Shahu | Maratha King | Elated, honored Vishwanath |
| Nizam | Hyderabad ruler | Stayed neutral, self-preservation |
| Yesubhai | Hostage | Released, returned to Marathas |
| Madan Singh | Hostage | Sambhaji's "half son," released |
| Bhanu | Peshwa official | Carried originals, different route |
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1719 | Farooq Shiar rejects Syed brothers' demands |
| 1719 | Emperor flees to women's quarters |
| 1719 | 1,000 Marathas killed in Delhi streets |
| 1719 | Farooq Shiar found, blinded, imprisoned |
| 1719 | Rafi-ul-Darajat installed as puppet emperor |
| 1719 | Farooq Shiar tries to escape to Jodhpur |
| 1719 | Syed brothers have him assassinated |
| 1719 | Three imperial orders signed for Marathas |
| 1719 | Ambush on Bajirao Vishwanath's group |
| 1719 | Official killed but originals safe |
| 1719 | Bajirao Vishwanath returns to Pune triumphant |
What The Marathas Got
The Complete Victory
| Order | What It Granted | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| #1 | Tax collection rights in 6 Deccan provinces | Massive revenue stream |
| #2 | Sardeshmukhi (10% additional tax) | Even more money |
| #3 | Recognition of Maratha Kingdom | LEGITIMACY |
| Bonus | Chautai rights (25% tax) | Huge financial base |
| Bonus | Release of hostages (Yesubhai, Madan Singh) | Family reunions |
Critical Insights
1. The Chaos Creates Opportunity
The Situation:
- Mughal court in chaos
- Coup happening
- Emperor being hunted
- Violence in streets
- 1,000 Marathas killed
The Result:
- Perfect time to get demands met
- Syed brothers need allies
- Will sign anything
- Puppet emperor = rubber stamp
The Lesson:
- Crisis = opportunity
- When empire weak = extract maximum
- Balaji Vishwanath timed it perfectly
2. The Puppet Emperor Strategy
Why Syed Brothers Needed One:
- Can't rule directly (not royal blood)
- Need legitimacy
- Must have figurehead
- Find compliant princeling
Why Rafi-ul-Darajat:
- No power base
- Will do what they say
- From royal family (legitimacy)
- Controllable
The Marionette Metaphor:
"People who have these dolls that they operate by remote."
- Perfect description
- Emperor = puppet
- Syed brothers = puppeteers
- Signs whatever they want
3. The Women's Protection Network
Why They Wouldn't Release Bidar Ali:
- Protecting princelings
- Fear of mass slaughter
- Syed brothers might kill all royal family
- Taking over = eliminating rivals
- Multiple wives/concubines = many princes to protect
The Calculation:
- If Syed brothers win = might kill all princes
- Can't trust their intentions
- Better to hide and protect
- Survival of royal line
4. The Blinding Strategy
Why Blind Instead of Kill:
- Blinded emperor = can't rule (Islamic law)
- Disqualified from throne
- But still alive (mercy?)
- Prison insurance
Why Kill Later:
- Escape attempt = too dangerous
- Rajput connection = potential army
- Could gather support
- Come back with force
- Must eliminate completely
5. The Rajput Escape Plan
Why Jodhpur:
- Wife's family
- Rajput military power
- Autonomous kingdom
- Could provide protection
- Base for comeback
The Danger:
- Rajputs = warrior caste
- Could raise army
- March on Delhi
- Restore Farooq Shiar
- Syed brothers' nightmare
Why Kill Him:
- Can't risk it
- Too dangerous alive
- Must eliminate option
- Final solution
6. The Smart Document Strategy
The Split:
- Copies to Bajirao Vishwanath
- Originals to Bhanu
- Different routes
- Insurance policy
Why This Worked:
- Ambushers went for wrong target
- Got copies, killed official
- But originals safe
- Mission accomplished
The Planning:
- Anticipated ambush
- Prepared backup plan
- Protected the prize
- Professional execution
7. The Hardliner Opposition
Who Opposed:
- Conservative nobles
- Anti-Maratha faction
- Lost land to grants
- Saw it as weakness
What They Did:
- Ambushed Bajirao's group
- Killed official
- Tried to steal orders
- Prevent implementation
Why It Failed:
- Got wrong documents
- Originals escaped
- Can't stop it now
- Emperor signed it
8. The Legitimacy Revolution
What Changed:
"Aurangzeb said they were always illegitimate, just some rebels."
Now:
- Imperial recognition
- Legitimate kingdom
- No longer rebels
- Official status
Why This Mattered:
- Can't be dismissed as bandits
- Must be respected as kingdom
- Legal standing
- Treaties have weight
- Ambassadors recognized
The Power:
"Nobody could say 'where is your legitimacy?' Because the Mughals had accepted it."
9. Bajirao's Education
What The 20-Year-Old Learned:
Lesson #1: Mughal Empire Is Finished
- Saw chaos firsthand
- Coups and murders
- No real power
- "Only effective in Delhi alone"
Lesson #2: Power Vacuum Exists
- Empire collapsing
- No one in charge
- Up for grabs
- Opportunity
Lesson #3: How Court Politics Works
- Saw negotiations
- Saw bribes and deals
- Saw violence
- Saw puppet emperors
Lesson #4: Timing Is Everything
- Strike when enemy weak
- Exploit chaos
- Maximum extraction
- Don't miss opportunity
The Impact:
"It influenced all of his decisions and battles after that."
His Future:
- Becomes greatest Peshwa
- Expands empire massively
- Never loses battle
- All based on this insight
- "Whole thing is coming down"
10. The Shivaji Parallel
Both Saw Firsthand:
- Shivaji at Agra (strong empire)
- Bajirao at Delhi (weak empire)
- Both got reality check
- Both learned from experience
The Difference:
- Shivaji saw: Must rebel carefully (strong enemy)
- Bajirao saw: Must expand aggressively (weak enemy)
The Common Thread:
- Don't rely on rumors
- See for yourself
- Firsthand intelligence
- Shape strategy from reality
11. The Paper Tiger Realization
What Bajirao Understood:
"Mughal empire is gone. And that there's a power vacuum forming."
The Contrast:
- Aurangzeb's terror and rule = gone
- Now = "paper tiger"
- Looks impressive
- No real power
The Strategy This Enables:
- Aggressive expansion (Bajirao's future)
- Direct challenges
- Not afraid of emperor
- Take what you want
12. The Neutrality Calculation
Nizam's Choice:
- Powerful enough to intervene
- Chose to stay neutral
- Self-preservation
- Let others fight it out
Why This Mattered:
- Could have saved Farooq Shiar
- Didn't want to risk it
- Better to wait and see
- Pick winning side later
The Pattern:
- Smart players stay neutral in uncertain coups
- Let chaos resolve itself
- Then ally with winner
- Minimize risk
The Three Orders in Detail
Order #1: Six Provinces Tax Rights
What:
- Collection rights in 6 Deccan provinces
- Massive territory
- Huge revenue
Impact:
- Financial independence
- Don't need Mughal payments
- Direct taxation
- Economic power base
Order #2: Sardeshmukhi (10%)
What:
- Additional 10% tax
- On top of Chauth (25%)
- Total = 35% of all revenue!
Impact:
- Enormous wealth
- Fund armies
- Expand operations
- Self-sufficient
Order #3: Kingdom Recognition
What:
- Official acceptance of Maratha Kingdom
- No longer rebels
- Legitimate sovereign state
Impact:
- Legal standing
- International recognition
- Treaties have weight
- Can't be dismissed
- GAME CHANGER
Where We Left Off
The Situation:
- Farooq Shiar dead (blinded, imprisoned, then killed)
- Puppet emperor installed (Rafi-ul-Darajat)
- Marathas got everything they wanted:
- 6 provinces tax rights
- Sardeshmukhi (10%)
- Chauth (25%)
- Kingdom recognition (HUGE!)
- Hostages released (Yesubhai, Madan Singh)
- Hardliners tried to steal orders (failed)
- Originals safe with Bhanu
- Official killed in ambush (but had copies)
- Shahu delighted
- Balaji Vishwanath honored
- Bajirao (20 years old) learned crucial lesson:
- Mughal empire = paper tiger
- Power vacuum forming
- "Whole thing is coming down"
The Future:
- Bajirao will become greatest Peshwa
- Use this insight to expand massively
- Never lose a battle
- All from what he saw in Delhi at age 20
- Understanding: Empire is finished
A 20-year-old boy walked into Delhi and saw an empire collapse in real time. He saw an emperor blinded and murdered. He saw puppets installed. He saw his father extract everything they wanted from chaos. And he learned the most important lesson of his life: "The Mughal emperor is only effective in Delhi alone. Beyond that, nobody gives him a damn. The whole thing is coming down." That boy - Bajirao - would become the greatest Peshwa in Maratha history. And everything he did, every battle he won, every territory he conquered, came from understanding what he saw in those bloody streets of Delhi in 1719: there's a power vacuum, and it's up for grabs.